Source for information on constitutional interpretation. Constitutional law exam notes general principles of characterisation introduction for the law to be valid it must be characterised to bring it within the scope of the legislative powers conferred upon the cth parliament. Time chart of the united states supreme court a1 appendix b. Constitutional courts, constitutional interpretation, and. First, the author examines some of the normative considerations for and against judges openly articulating and consistently applying allembracing approaches to constitutional interpretation a development that. Constitutional interpretationconstitutional interpretation comprehends the methods or strategies available to people attempting to resolve disputes about the meaning or application of the constitution. Selected theories of constitutional interpretation congressional research service 2 theories should be applied.
Germanys constitution of 1949 with amendments through 2012. More than what the supreme court says pdf, 108kb, extensions, fall 2008. Those two words are now so loaded with politics that theyve lost meaning and arent very useful in a constitutional conversation. Castan centre for human rights law monash university. The second part strives to elaborate on certain methods of constitutional interpretation in the light of these moral concerns, arguing that constitutional interpretation should be guided by moral reasons and that it ought to be detached from any need to consult the framers purposes or intentions. Constitutional interpretation in the socalled hard cases. While an exhaustive examination of all of the cases in which judges have outlined methods of constitutional interpretation is beyond the scope of this essay, a number of general points can be made about the state of constitutional interpretation as it exists in this country based on an examination of a number of prominent cases. Randall kelso, styles of constitutional interpretation and the four main approaches to. Constitution to substitute for the race power in paragraph xxvi a new provision, the. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. Due to the challenges of extracting text from pdfs, it will.
The process of constitutional interpretation is twofold as stated by mchugh j in re dingjan. Away from institutionalism and toward individualism 100. In a democratic society, questions of constitutional law require a political dialogue that involves all three branches of the national government, all fifty states, and the general public. The role of the supreme court in interpreting the constitution when the supreme court issues an opinion, it is binding on the litigants, is enforced by the u. In kartinyeri v commonwealth, the minister held the power of making declarations for the purpose of protecting the areas of aboriginals. Shabalala v the attorneygeneral of transvaal nyamakazi v president of bophuthatswana. Principles of constitutional interpretation constitutional interpretation, or constitutional construction, the term more often used by the founders, is the process by which legal decisions are made that are justified by a constitution, although not necessarily correctly. Styles of constitutional interpretation and the four main. Zywicki in this article, professor pritchard and professor zywicki examine the role of tradition in constitutional interpretation, a topic that has received significant attention in recent years. However, a court still has to give meaning and substance to the constitutional rights values even though the meaning thereof is often unclear.
Revisiting s v makwanyane 5 rely on international and foreign law that supports his or her own preconceived notions. Transcript of proceedings, kartinyeri v commonwealth 5 february 1998 31. Judicial interpretation refers to different ways that the judiciary uses to interpret the law, particularly constitutional documents and legislation. The race powerits replacement and interpretation 2012 austlii. This short paper considers some questions regarding constitutional interpretation. I conclude that, while international law has had and should have a role to play in constitutional interpretation, a robust role for international newcrest mining wa v the commonwealth 1997 190 clr 5, 657 newcrest. Justice kirby also found assistance in the approach of the us supreme court to the consideration of racially discriminatory legislation. A preliminary observation of the ethiopian system the present mechanism of constitutional adjudication in ethiopia demonstrates unique features. Developments oxford academic journals oxford university press. Methods of constitutional interpretation oxbridge notes. A textualist is an originalist who gives primary weight to the text and structure of the constitution.
Constitutional interpretation in the so called hard. Kartinyeri v commonwealth 1998 195 clr 337, 41719 kirby j. Altered meanings justin malbon there are many words which have been made to suffer constant misuse. Would, or should, this make any difference to the interpretation of laws enacted under section 51xxvi that apply to indigenous people. If every constitutional question were to be decided by public political. High court of australia, a decision in the case of kartinyeri v the.
And see also kartinyeri v the commonwealth 1998 195 clr 337,417418 kartinyeri, sinanovic v r. One of the landmark decisions given by the high court was the case of kartinyeri v commonwealth1 where section 51xxvi of the constitution was interpreted. A supreme constitution must be given a generous and purposive interpretation. But the high court in kartinyeri v commonwealth 199811 resisted an interpretation of the race power as restricted, or permitting laws which only benefit the people of the particular race. Section 51xxvi of the commonwealth constitution authorises parliament to make laws with respect to the people of any race for whom it is deemed necessary to make special laws. Kartinyeri v commonwealth 1 is amongst the leading cases of the high court in the matter of interpretation of constitution s section 51 xxvi and this matter was related to the application of this section to the australian indigenous people. The significance of the approaches to constitutional interpretation in s v mhlungu 19957 bclr 793cc by richard neville crause boardman submitted in part fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of master of laws. The con is the supreme law, and the state including the government is bound by a system of fundamental values such as justice and equality. Constitutional interpretation 89 speaking up and speaking more 98 exhibit 2. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise cambridge core to connect with your account.
A sophisticated recognition that constitutional interpretation inevitably requires choices to be made and that these choices can be guided by a general orientation either to expand federal power as far as possible or to read federal power with an eye to the resulting impact on the remaining legislative powers of the states. Constitutional interpretation, or constitutional construction, the term more often used by the founders, is the process by which legal decisions are made that are justified by a constitution, although not necessarily correctly. Australia has neither a constitutional bill of rights nor a statutory bill of rights. In kartinyeri no majority emerged on that crucial beneficialdetrimental law. The letters of the constitution are fairly static and not very easy to change but the laws enacted by the legislature reflect the current state of people and are very dynamic.
The constitutional principle is judicial restraint. Pdf constitutional interpretation in a globalised world. Constitutional courts, constitutional interpretation, subnational constitutionalism, statute of catalonia, direct democracy, religious freedom except where otherwise noted content on this site is licensed under a creative commons 2. The following are some of the general principles formulated by sa courts. The preamble of the ic expressly referred to sa as a constitutional state. Theories of constitutional interpretation modern democracy invites us to replace the notion of a regime founded upon laws, of a legitimate power, by the notion of a regime founded upon the legitimacy of a debate as to what is legitimate and what is illegitimatea debate which is necessarily without any guarantor and without any end. Essay the modes of constitutional interpretation 37 appendix a.
In addition, the constitution is subject to interpretation in the light of changes since 1901. Common law constitutional interpretation virtually everyone would agree that sometimes the text is decisive. The court and constitutional interpretation e qual. Kartinyeri v the commonwealth of australia altonaer stiftung fur. Biographical chart of supreme court justices since 1900 b1 appendix c. Encyclopedia of the american constitution dictionary. Principles of constitutional interpretation introduction. International law as a tool of constitutional interpretation.
The court and constitutional interpretation the republic endures and this is the. The principles of constitutional interpretation the. In interpreting the constitution, the justices of the high court have in many. This article analyses this development in light of prior case law and the views of other current members of the high court. I did so, in part, by reference to the parliamentary record. Constitutional interpretation by andrei marmor ssrn. The use of international law in constitutional interpretation in. We also stock notes on constitutional law as well as law notes generally. The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the pdf sample above, taken from our constitutional outlines. Constitutional interpretation law library of congress. Via an analysis of the reasons for judgement in kartinyeri v the commonwealth of australia this paper contends that an imper ative of extinguishment of aboriginal sovereignty continuously informs. Just as bill wentworth was always here when his health.
The role of the supreme court in interpreting the constitution. Through the insertion of this section in the constitution of australia, the discrimination against a specific section of the community has been allowed, particularly on the basis of the race of such people2. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Iii constitutional interpretation and international law in australia. Constitutional interpretation kristen walker justice kirby of the high court of australia has recently begun to use international law in his interpretation of the australian constitution. First australians, law and the high court of australia the hon michael kirby ac cmg introduction and outline professor mick dodson, russell taylor, principal of the institute, professor barry dexter and members of the wentworth family, georgina and mara, who are here today. In 1967, following a constitutional referendum, the words other than the aboriginal race in any state had been deleted from section 51xxvi.
Kartinyeri v the commonwealth of australia valerie kerruish abstract. The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the pdf sample above, taken from our constitutional law notes. Constitutional interpretation under the new south african order adrians janet hofmeyr a dissertation submitted to the faculty of law, university of the witwatersrand, johannesburg, in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of master of. Dr kartinyeri and neville golan appealed to the hight court, submitting that the act was invalid.
Interpretation anne twomey abstract the expert panel on the constitutional recognition of indigenous australians has recommended the repeal of the race power in the constitution and its replacement with a power to make laws with respect to aboriginal and torres strait islander peoples. The kartinyeri judgment illustrates the methods of constitutional interpretation the. Kartinyeri v commonwealth 1998 195 clr 337 law case. Notably kirby j in dissent found the law to be beyond the scope of. Ex parte applicants m2762003 by their next friend gs9 and minister for immigration and multicultural and indigenous affairs v al khafaji. Via an analysis of the reasons for judgement in kartinyeri. The court a quo adopted a restrictive interpretation of what constitutes a wellknown trade mark in terms of south african trade mark law and found, on an. The mechanism does not belong to any of the constitutional adjudication models operating in other countries. And madison had written that constitutional interpretation must be left to the reasoned judgment of independent judges, rather than to the tumult and conflict of the political process. Kartinyeri v the commonwealth 1998 195 clr 337, 37881 8289. Styles of constitutional interpretation and the four main approaches to consitutional interpretation in american legal history r. The result is that two of the court did not even consider the interpretation of s51xxvi.
The constitution of the united states d1 appendix e. Were it otherwise, repeal or amendment could easily become a stratagem adopted by a legislature eager to circumvent the proper scrutiny of constitutional validity. Constitutional controversies are about whether an official act is consistent with, and authorized by, a. Michael kirby, constitutional law and indigenous australians. Ronald kahn, author of the supreme court and constitutional theory, 19531993 a timely, important, meticulously researched, and wellwritten book that makes a valuable contribution to constitutional theory and is the best work on constitutional interpretation that i have read. Submissionindigenous constitional recognition monash university. This is an extract of our the commerce clause document, which we sell as part of our constitutional outlines collection written by the top tier of u. However, many supreme court decisions have been actively opposed by significant segments of.
1374 1041 841 1200 875 245 140 1167 655 1497 1506 1228 875 807 64 289 1062 1154 896 1086 124 689 552 830 392 124 990 1186 688 640 458 674 1237 1048 417 953 1133 5 1197 1060